Dining This Week

Mario’s Pizzeria 

By SHERLEY BUCKLAND

Mario’s Pizzeria in Beaufort Square shopping center has long been a popular dining spot for locals. Last December, ownership changed hands and the new owner, Mark Turkneimer, has spent the last year renovating the restaurant and updating the menu, which is no small undertaking. His hard work is paying off, and Mario’s is a welcoming, smoke free, family friendly dining establishment with an extensive, budget-conscious menu. 

I was really looking forward to my visit at Mario’s for two reasons: one, it had been a while since I had dined at there, and I will admit, my last experience was not the most favorable; and two, this was the first time a restaurant owner exuberantly insistent that the photographer and I bring our families.

Upon my arrival, I was introduced to Mark and his apprentice cook, Kevin Chunn.  After a brief tour of the tastefully renovated establishment, Mark and Kevin retreated to the kitchen and began preparing what seemed like every item on the menu. 

We began with a beautiful antipasto salad—a nice bed of greens topped with provolone, ham and salami rolls, sliced red onion, pepperoncinis, tomatoes, black olives and cucumbers, garnished with pepperoni.  This salad is usually served with the house Italian vinaigrette dressing, which you must try.  In Italian culture, the antipasto is a dish served in anticipation of, or before, the pasta meal.

The garlic bread with cheese is supposed to be an appetizer, but could be a meal itself.  Fresh Italian bread is brushed with garlic butter, topped with fresh mozzarella cheese, baked to melt the cheese, and served with homemade marinara sauce. 

The chicken parmesan tied with the cannolis for third place on my list of favorite items at Mario’s. The chicken breast is cut in house and hand pounded for tenderness. Next it is breaded, baked and topped with fresh marinara and mozzarella then served over a bed of pasta.  Mmm, mmm, mmm.

If you prefer a chicken entrée without a red sauce, then I would recommend the chicken francese.  Chicken francese is a tender chicken breast filet dipped in an egg batter, lightly sautéed in olive oil and served over pasta.  The meal is delicate yet filling.

Also on the menu is ravioli filled with fresh ricotta cheese the diameter of a baseball, oven baked in the sauce of your choice and topped with melted mozzarella. My son, the pickiest eater in the family, ate several of these mouth-watering creations. 

Speaking of sauces, Mario’s offers many.  The pizza sauce is a red sauce made specifically for the pizzas, while marinara is the red sauce used for pasta dishes. 

The gray sauce (which is actually brownish red in color) is the “old world style” sauce that meatballs and sausage are cooked in. Mario’s meat sauce is marinara with meat cooked in.  There are also alfredo sauces, double clam sauces and a sauce for scampi.

The shrimp scampi took second place on my list with its tender shrimp sautéed in olive oil and tossed with pasta, garlic and onion spice with a touch of lemon and white wine.  Amazing how the simplest ingredients and preparation make the biggest impressions.  On my next visit, I will be ordering the scampi and the clams in white sauce—which I gave top honors. 

The clams in white sauce have a robust flavor and a broth that you will want to drink from a mug.  Being careful not to give all the details away, Mark did share a few key ingredients; garlic, white wine, aioli and double clams. Cherry stone clams are finely chopped and cooked into the broth that is served over littleneck clams.  All the clams are fresh from Russell’s Creek Shellfish. 

There is also a dish of clams in a red sauce that is full of chopped garlic and stuffed clams, which are chopped and separated from their juices.  The juices are then used in preparing a homemade stuffing mix that the chopped clams are added back into.  The entire mixture is “stuffed” back into the clamshells and baked.  Delicious. 

Three types of lasagna available at Mario’s: regular lasagna, which is basically layers of pasta and cheeses; meat lasagna, prepared with the meat sauce; and spinach lasagna, with chopped spinach folded into the ricotta cheese mixture. 

Keep in mind that every dish at Mario’s is cooked to order and substitutions or special requests are accommodated to the best of the chef’s abilities. 

There is every type of pizza topping available and some pretty tasty suggestions like the vegetarian pizza; a pizza topped with eggplant, spinach, mushrooms and artichoke or the surfer pizza; or a pizza topped with pineapple, Canadian bacon, feta cheese and hot peppers.  All are quite tasty, and definitely a break from the norm. 

Huge calzones and stromboli are also available.  The pizza crusts are hand thrown and every pizza, calzone and stromboli are baked in Mario’s brick pizza oven. 

Dessert choices at Mario’s include New York style cheesecake and cannolis.  If you really want to treat yourself and your guests to a little something special this holiday season, order the cannolis.  Better yet, call Mark ahead of time and see if he can get the mini cannoli shells.  They are addicting.  The homemade cream filling Mark prepares for them is rich, creamy, and laced with tiny chocolate chips.  I love the combination of sweet cream filling and crispy pastry shell.

Mario’s is able to accommodate any size party.  Birthdays, sports team events and family gatherings are encouraged. 

Mark strives to make Mario’s a great family restaurant where everyone is happy, comfortable, and well fed.  With prices that are hard to beat for the quality and amount of food you receive, pick Mario’s for your next dinner out.

Enjoy!

 

  Quick Bites

Location: 1704 Live Oak St. in the Beaufort Square Shopping Center .

Phone: (252) 728-6602.

Hours: Lunch and dinner served Tuesday through Thursday from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., and Friday and Saturday from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.

Reservations: Appreciated for parties of 10 or more.

Payment Options: Cash, MasterCard, Visa, Discover.

12/01/06



See the previously reviewed restaurants on the Restaurant Archive page

Back to THIS WEEK MAGAZINE Index